Friday, December 10, 2010

Stop Fortress North America: Don’t Let the Harper Government Make a Secret Deal with Washington

The Harper government is engaged in secret talks with the U.S. government to negotiate a sweeping Fortress North America security deal with Washington.

For over a decade, Fortress North America has been a favourite goal of the political right and continental business. The deal poses a major threat to Canadian sovereignty. Whatever proponents of the deal say, its implementation will force Canada to harmonize its immigration and refugee policies with those of the United States. And it will require Canadian government agencies to share much more private information about Canadian citizens and residents with American agencies than they already do. The deal will invite the FBI and the CIA right into our lives.

For those who think that this won’t matter much, it is vital to remember that what happened to Maher Arar nearly a decade ago was precipitated by the Canadian government’s sharing of information with the U.S. He was the canary in the mine shift----the warning that many more of us could be next.

Canada has already moved a long way down the road to defence arrangements with the U.S. that could conceivably allow the U.S. to effectively seize control of Canada during a global geo-political crisis.

The sweetener for the deal that is now in the works is that its ratification will mean quicker shipments of goods across the Canada-U.S. border. This is hardly a vital matter for Canada. It’s true that over the past two years Canada’s exports to the U.S. have plunged. But that’s because the U.S. has a weaker economy than it did before the crash and its demand for our products has declined. Such a development should motivate us to find other partners for commerce around the world, not to climb ever more into a relationship with a country whose global economic power is in decline.

The only reason we know about the secret talks between Ottawa and Washington is because of media leaks. The plan is to unveil the deal with Washington in January. Then a joint ceremony is to be held with Stephen Harper and Barack Obama appending their signatures to the agreement. After that, the details of the deal are to be hammered out between officials from the two countries.

In the meantime, the members of the Harper government refuse to say a word about this.

We know from WikiLeaks that CSIS is home to those who believe that Canadians are naïve about the threat of terrorism. We can expect the members of the Harper government to get lurid about the danger of terrorists when the deal with Washington is made public. The truth is that we now face a real threat to our nation’s sovereignty from those who hold the highest offices in the land.

Canadians need to get loud right now to stop this covert attack on our national sovereignty. Despite the chest-thumping phony patriotism and flag waving of the Harperites and their friends, this government has always been committed to a deeper continental union with the United States, an idea that is profoundly contrary to the interests of Canadians, now and in the future.

All of us need to take on this fight. We can’t leave this one to the tepid opposition parties in the House of Commons.

13 comments:

James Umpherson said...

While I am no Harperite and have always advocated development of greater economic trading diversification, this decision has been long since implemented in the past through the Security and Prosperity Partnership (SPP).

Since the lapse of the SPP, it has been the Canadian government's, whether Liberal or Conservative, to pursue a bi-lateral rather than a tri-lateral agreement with the Americans on fortress North, North America.

What has changed? Canadians only see what is on their doorstep and believe that a continued connection to an empire, even a declining one, is better than risking the unknown. Just ask your brethren of the CAW, NDP, and other Ontario based advocacy groups.

Anonymous said...

Prof. James:
We are chaining ourselves to a corpse. The US is facing the fate that England faced after WWll. We should be part of an emerging group of mid-weight powers -- Turkey, Brazil, etc. But we won't join. It will take another debacle like the Iraq war to put paid to the American hegemony and force a change. That's coming in the form of an unwinnable war with Iran.
But it's important for the left to raise the issue and question our membership in NATO, an alliance whose raison d'etre, if it ever had one, was buried under the rubble of the Soviet Union.

Richard Sharp said...

Government secrecy is a scourge on our democracy. It's taken far greater hold since the Access to Information Act codified discretionary secrets. And the resultant opposite of open government, security of information laws and policies. Then came 9/11 and we've headed far further south since then.

Joe Hueglin said...

Canadians need to get loud right now to stop this covert attack on our national sovereignty. Despite the chest-thumping phony patriotism and flag waving of the Harperites and their friends, this government has always been committed to a deeper continental union with the United States, an idea that is profoundly contrary to the interests of Canadians, now and in the future.

All of us need to take on this fight. We can’t leave this one to the tepid opposition parties in the House of Commons.
http://blog.jameslaxer.com/2010/12/stop-fortress-north-america-dont-let.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed:+JamesLaxer+(James+Laxer)

James that you wrote "now and in the future." rather than "as it was in the beginning, now and in the future" - that is the position of those of us who trace our positioning back to the founder of our country. There are times when progressive-conservatism melds with other's views - and this is one of them!

There are times our interests and those of the United States of America coincide. There are other times their directions are not the best direction for us.- and we must have the liberty of making the choice.

Such would not be the case whatever the terms presented. "Fat and skinny went to bed" is the first part of the saying. - Canada is skinny.

We have common cause, he continuance of independent decision making for our country.

Joe Hueglin
Member 29th Parliament
joe.hueglin@bellnet.ca

Richard Sharp said...

Mr. Heuglin, please name the interest where we coincide with the Americans on this file.

Everything I can think of, from national security to individual freedom and privacy, goes the other way.

Richard Sharp said...

Wikeleaks is the biggest game-changer since 9/11. No doubt in my mind.

Think about it. There are around 200 countries and countless corporations who are keeping secrets from us, to extract more taxes, prices, fees or whatever.

As citizens and consumers, we are being hosed.

But loyalty to the wrong cause will eventually lead to whistle-blowing. Far as I know, it took just one of a 100k recipients of the American diplomatic cables to blow the whistle.

The wrong cause is defined as harming others without reason. There will be no end to snitching of that sort.

Joe Hueglin said...

"Everything I can think of, from national security to individual freedom and privacy, goes the other way."

All has been going their way. There is no threat to Canada that has not existed before. There is no need for a few warplanes but for search and rescue to my latest knowledge. My wife lost a nail file. That it posed a dange is nonsense.

Here's the music to play when we make a Highland charge against Harper and is henchmen (and women)


.....Joe
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYJqMUJFY1g&feature=related

.....Joe

Richard Sharp said...

Mr. Hueglin, perhaps I misinterpreted your post. I fervently believe that the USA could be our salvation as a planetary savior. But that it is blowing it, big time.

Totally caught up in cold war/terror/military stuff and digging up dirt on other world leaders.

The world could do a lot better.

Anonymous said...

STAN SAID:
Fortress America means that when once when Canadians travelled abroad we could wear Canadian insignia to protect us from the worldwide hatred of Americans.
Now and as we become more and more a U.S.. satellite that Canadian protection is disappearing and we are identifies with the abusive American power.

Bill Bell said...

For those of us who are already mistrustful of Canadian government security agencies of all kinds as well as the courts any development along these lines is bad news. Freedoms and safeguards are gushing away and Canadians do nothing. I can't say anything new. We lack the means to present alternative points of view to mass audiences and we have no potent representation in government.

Nonetheless I am grateful to you for writing this.

Anonymous said...

Harper and obama are tools of Corporate interests. who will erode our hard earned rights and benifits. closer ties with the empire is economic suicide

John said...

Once the Mulroney Government accepted a bribe from the American Government, the push forward to merge our economies was a foregone conclusion, and all without citizen approval.

Stewart said...

Ahhh, this explains the push towards having mandatory minimum sentences for cannabis offenders.

To be wed the two countries must have similar law and order regimes I would think.

It horrifies me, but anyone I tell about it pretty much laughs and talks about how it would never happen.

I have lost a lot of respect for Canadians since Harper came to power, they mostly seem to be sheep.

Thanks for the post sir.

Stewart